Jump to content

Trade Scenario


Falkonator
 Share

Recommended Posts

So this morning I wondered what,to do with our MLB spot. And came up with This trade idea.

Falcons trade pick round 1 and pick round 5

Eagles trade pick round 1 MLB Mychal Kendricks and pick round 4

We swap 1sts get a 4th and a young MLB to run our Defense.

The eagles move up to the top 10 can select Amari Cooper or Kevin White, tre wayens etc.

Why they,do this trade is based on the fact that they resigned D.Ryans,Traded for Kiko and Kendrixks is in the last year of his deal.

Why we do this, we trade back still have a top 20 pick(19) get a young MLb and an additional 4th

With that 1st we can draft Randy Gregory, landon Collins, etc..

What are your thoughts.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Naw I wouldn't trade back unless we get a 2nd 4th and then a 5th the following year. No need to trade back if our guy is there at 8

a stud MLB and a S(Collins) for basically our 1st sounds better than Shane Ray assuming of course Beasley and Fowler are of the board.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

It takes a lot more value to move up from 19 to 8. Check the chart. If you value their lb on a 1 year deal as a 4th, they'd still need to pony up 2 firsts just to start the discussion.

if I remember correctly some team traded a 1 and 3 last year to move up, I doubt Philly would trade 2 1sts and kendricks for our pick. Trying to stay realistic here. Prob their 1,3 and kendricks for our 1 and 5. But no way 2 1sts.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not worth it, IMO. Giving up too much draft capital.

where not really giving anything up, we still have a 1st that we can use to draft Dupree,Gregory or Collins.

Where getting a young MLB with loads of talent

and an additional 4th while losing a 5th.

So basically with our 1st we get Mychal Kendricks and we'll say Landon Collins. With our 2nd we draft Preston Smith or Danielle Hunter.

So with 2 picks we address MLB,Pass rush and Safety.

Now I wouldn't mind trading down from #2 To the middle of the 2nd while adding another 3rd or 4th Round pick to still acquire Smith or Hunter in the later part of round #2.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

if I remember correctly some team traded a 1 and 3 last year to move up, I doubt Philly would trade 2 1sts and kendricks for our pick. Trying to stay realistic here. Prob their 1,3 and kendricks for our 1 and 5. But no way 2 1sts.

Just trying to share the facts with you. The value chart says they'd have to give up thier 1st, 2nd, and 3rd for #8. Normally the team moving up pays a premium. With rookie pay being slotted, the value of lottery picks is even greater than when the chart was created.

http://www.draftcountdown.com/features/Value-Chart.php

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just trying to share the facts with you. The value chart says they'd have to give up thier 1st, 2nd, and 3rd for #8. Normally the team moving up pays a premium. With rookie pay being slotted, the value of lottery picks is even greater than when the chart was created.

http://www.draftcountdown.com/features/Value-Chart.php

I do t think many actually use the chart, it's more of a guide not a set thing,but I get what Ur saying.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

They would be dumb dumb dumb to get rid of Mychal Kendricks. So i would be all for that move, but i don't see it as realistic.

it would be shocking but with them keeping g ryans while adding Kiko,I could see it as a possibility they try and move kendricks before his contract expires and he Walks in FA next off-season.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

where not really giving anything up, we still have a 1st that we can use to draft Dupree,Gregory or Collins.

Where getting a young MLB with loads of talent

and an additional 4th while losing a 5th.

So basically with our 1st we get Mychal Kendricks and we'll say Landon Collins. With our 2nd we draft Preston Smith or Danielle Hunter.

So with 2 picks we address MLB,Pass rush and Safety.

Now I wouldn't mind trading down from #2 To the middle of the 2nd while adding another 3rd or 4th Round pick to still acquire Smith or Hunter in the later part of round #2.

The difference from 20 to 8 is worth more than the difference between a 4th and 5th and a LB entering thelast year of his rookie deal.

MLB is a relatively easy position to fill unless you're talking a generational player like Keuchly/Urlacher. I'd rather just draft a guy in the 2nd/3rd.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

who do you draft if both are gone?

I'm greedy, so based on your scenario if we trade that far back I expect a future 1st, a 2nd pick this year along with a fourth. As far as who I would choose would depend. I would probably say Eli Harold (1st), Eric Rowe (2nd), and Ali Marpet (2nd - 2nd round pick), but I rather have Beasley/Flower and Anthony

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The difference from 20 to 8 is worth more than the difference between a 4th and 5th and a LB entering thelast year of his rookie deal.

MLB is a relatively easy position to fill unless you're talking a generational player like Keuchly/Urlacher. I'd rather just draft a guy in the 2nd/3rd.

we would still get a pass rusher,a MLB(not easy to fill) With the swap of 1 pick. I see that as a win win, I look at it as what gives me the most 1 pick for 1 player(Beasley) or that same pick can get me 2 players(Kendrick s and Dupree) 2 is better than one and fills 2 Needs. Yea I could see it being a 3rs instead of their 4th. But didn't want to throw to much out their.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not trading the 1st round pick...trade the 2nd and get two 3rds and two 4ths and build this team

Ur gettin. A 1st + a LB for our 1st tho? Not really losing anything, u can still draft Dupree at 19. I'm sure the Beasley lovers would hate this idea, while I'm not worried about the name of the player, more so the position. We still get a pass rusher,while adding.g a young fix 2 spots with 1 pick is a winner in my book.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not trading the 1st round pick...trade the 2nd and get two 3rds and two 4ths and build this team

There hasn't been any talk on trading the second rounder that I have seen. That would be a thought ! Swap 2nds and then pick up a couple other picks. Depends on the way the draft falls ?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

we would still get a pass rusher,a MLB(not easy to fill) With the swap of 1 pick. I see that as a win win, I look at it as what gives me the most 1 pick for 1 player(Beasley) or that same pick can get me 2 players(Kendrick s and Dupree) 2 is better than one and fills 2 Needs. Yea I could see it being a 3rs instead of their 4th. But didn't want to throw to much out their.

Having a GREAT MLB isn't easy to fill. Finding a guy like Kendricks is pretty easy if you're willing to put a 2nd/3rd into that spot.

And really, given Philly's moves, they don't have a lot of leverage in moving this guy. He's a player thats going to need to be extended which means a team has to either extend him without truly knowing how he'll work in their system, franchise him, or risk him having a good season and hitting UFA time. PLUS they just traded for a dude that could easily serve as a replacement assuming they don't want to run Alonso at Will.

LBs are sort of the RBs of the defense. A steady PIRATED VIDEO IS ILLEGAL of top of the league producers for picks after the 1st round. I think giving all of that up is simply too much for the chance to pay this guy $5m+ as soon as next year.

I'm not necessarily anti-trade. Its just a situation where the board has to fall a certain way.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

×
×
  • Create New...