Final Decision, What Criterion Is Rc Using When Evaluating/ranking A Qb?

[SaintsFanInLA]

It seems like every week the criteria used in RC is at best a moving target depending on where each poster's team's QB ranks in a certain category. So, this is it. This is my first poll here and I will try to do this right but the question is, which is more important in evaluating a QB, personal stats, regular season wins, playoff wins or for the x-factor, their respective defensive ranking?

[joe horn]

Write in vote for "throws the ball good"

[Rewind]

Write in vote for all of these above.

And adding in intangibles like making players around them better.

Edited December 31, 2013 by Rewind

[DD: Objective Elite]

Write in vote for 'pooping his pants'

[NYG4]

Write in vote for how he looks without a shirt on and his smile

[alwaysfallforward]

I voted individual stats, because it's the closest thing to how well he actually plays.

In the end, that's what matters in judging a QB. It is asinine to judge him by things that depend on factors that are out of his control, he only controls his own play.

[mvcrook]

Write in vote for "whatever advances my argument at the time"

[Utah_Saint]

"all of the above"

[Born A-Ginn]

None of those tell the full story on their own. Individual stats is the closest of the options, but even they can be misleading.

To me it's all about the eye test and how important that player is to their team.

[Willy Mo]

Whatever the **** I say.

[Atlien 404]

write in vote if they got a 1200 yard rusher or not

[SaintsFanInLA]

This might be the biggest moving target in RC.

[Atlien 404]

This might be the biggest moving target in RC.

true the only thing you can do is pick one and stay consistent with your pick

[Kevo]

You forgot "Has to have a birthmark on his face"

[jb 3.0]

Individual stats AND playoff wins. Plus, the ability to excercise a quarterback sneak like a man and not a 79 year old woman.

[Atlien 404]

Individual stats AND playoff wins. Plus, the ability to excercise a quarterback sneak like a man and not a 79 year old woman.

notice no one agrees with you ....look at the poll....you're on your own

[jb 3.0]

notice no one agrees with you ....look at the poll....you're on your own

Of course...I'd expect no different here. If you agreed it'd go against everything you all have been crowing about since 2008!

You seem to forget, I'm not one that expects or cares if folks agree with me.

[NYG4]

Individual stats AND playoff wins. Plus, the ability to excercise a quarterback sneak like a man and not a 79 year old woman.

I cackled..

Reminded me of this..

Edited December 31, 2013 by NYG4

[Big Bubba]

I've always been about stats, since wins are a team sport.

With Falcons now sucking... will Falcon fans still throw up Ryan's w/l record and pretend that it's his own personal stat? Or, are they on the boat now of , wins............... are not a qb stat?

[SaintRay]

Write in vote for it depends on who his Head Coach is.

[Atlien 404]

I've always been about stats, since wins are a team sport.

With Falcons now sucking... will Falcon fans still throw up Ryan's w/l record and pretend that it's his own personal stat? Or, are they on the boat now of , wins............... are not a qb stat?

depends are you son board with cam being a pretty average qb? Edited December 31, 2013 by still smokin

[Big Bubba]

depends are you son board with cam being a pretty average qb?

Meh. 92 TDs and over 13k yards in 3 years. Say what you want about him, but the guy has been a TD/Yardage monster.

[Big Bubba]

For comparison... I believe Ryan completed his 4th year....he had 97 TD... In four years, Ryan had 5 more TDs than Cam had in 3 years.

[Atlien 404]

Meh. 92 TDs and over 13k yards in 3 years. Say what you want about him, but the guy has been a TD/Yardage monster.

and say what you will bout wins being a team stat but ryan is a winner

[Big Bubba]

and say what you will bout wins being a team stat but ryan is a winner

Wins are a team effort.. always has been, always will be. Takes a good team to win on a regular basis. Ryan used to have a good team around him, that would allow him to kick a FG and capture that GWD, while his defense would sometimes hold the other teams offense. Team.........................Effort.