Jump to content

Falcan Moore's Consensus Top 120 Big Board


Recommended Posts

EDIT: Meant to post this in the draft forum, oh well. Mods can delete this one or leave it since this section of the board is more popular, but I'm reposting it there as well.

I decided to create this as a frame of reference for mock drafting. I may or may not update it, but at any rate, it should at least be very useful to get an idea of where the people really in the know believe certain players are going to be drafted. What I basically did was figure out which sites I've used over the years are the most accurate, and have drafts up right now, and narrowed it down to three (CBS Sports, Draft Insider, and Draft Countdown). Then I listed the high, the low, and the average, and ranked them according to that, along with where I believe they'll most likely go in a more vague sense so as to account for whether a pick “slipped” or is a “reach.” If there was a tie with the mean average, I used my own sense of who I believed was better as a factor in deciding who was ranked where. Sub 150 or unranked picks were largely postulate by myself of where they'd rank according to the site runner.

Hopefully some of you mockers find it useful. Should be great through the 4th or so.

Top 120 Big Board

1. Luke Joeckel, OT, Texas A&M | High: 1 | Low: 6 | Weighted Average: 2.67 | Consensus: Top Five

2. Bjoern Werner, DE, Florida St. | High: 2 | Low: 5 | Weighted Average: 3.67 | Consensus: Top Five

3. Damontre Moore, DE, Texas A&M | High: 1 | Low: 6 | Weighted Average: 3.67 | Consensus: Top Five

4. Star Lotulelei, DT, Utah | High: 2 | Low: 7 | Weighted Average: 4.00 | Consensus: Top Five

5. Jarvis Jones, OLB, Georgia | High: 2 | Low: 8 | Weighted Average: 4.33 | Consensus: Top Ten

6. Chance Warmack, OG, Alabama | High: 3 | Low: 7 | Weighted Average: 4.67 | Consensus: Top Ten

7. Dee Milliner, CB, Alabama | High: 5 | Low: 9 | Weighted Average: 7.67 | Consensus: Top Ten

8. Barkevious Mingo, OLB, LSU | High: 8 | Low: 9 | Weighted Average: 8.33 | Consensus: Top Ten

9. Eric Fisher, OT, Central Michigan | High: 6 | Low: 22 | Weighted Average: 11.67 | Consensus: Mid-High 1st

10. Sheldon Richardson, DT, Missouri | High: 10 | Low: 18 | Weighted Average: 13.00 | Consensus: Mid-High 1st

11. Geno Smith, QB, West Virginia | High: 13 | Low: 14 | Weighted Average: 13.67 | Consensus: Mid 1st

12. Johnathan Hankins, DT, Ohio St. | High: 5 | Low: 28 | Weighted Average: 15.00 | Consensus: Mid 1st

13. Jonathan Cooper, OG, North Carolina | High: 10 | Low: 20 | Weighted Average: 16.00 | Consensus: Mid 1st

14. Ezekial Ansah, DE, BYU | High: 11 | Low: 24 | Weighted Average: 17.00 | Consensus: Mid 1st

15. Keenan Allen, WR, California| High: 12| Low: 26 | Weighted Average: 17.00 |Consensus: Mid 1st

16. Kenny Vaccaro, S, Texas | High: 13 | Low: 26 | Weighted Average: 18.33 | Consensus: Mid 1st

17. Dion Jordan, DE, Oregon | High: 12 | Low: 27 | Weighted Average: 18.67 | Consensus: Mid 1st

18. Matt Barkley, QB, USC | High: 19 | Low: 23 | Weighted Average: 20.33 |Consensus: Mid 1st

19. Manti Te'o, ILB, Notre Dame | High: 10 | Low: 37 | Weighted Average: 20.67 | Consensus: Mid-Late 1st

20. Sam Montgomery, DE, LSU | High: 15 | Low: 32 | Weighted Average: 21.00 | Consensus: Mid-Late 1st

21. Zach Ertz, TE, Stanford | High: 17 | Low: 26 | Weighted Average: 22.33 | Consensus: Mid-Late 1st

22. Lane Johnson, OT, Oklahoma | High: 11 | Low: 31 | Weighted Average: 23.00 | Consensus: Mid-Late 1st

23. Sharrif Floyd, DT, Florida | High: 14 | Low: 39 | Weighted Average: 23.33 | Consensus: Mid-Late 1st

24. Alec Ogletree, OLB, Georgia| High: 18 | Low: 29 | Weighted Average: 23.67 | Consensus: Mid-Late 1st

25. Jesse Williams, DT, Alabama | High: 19 | Low: 30 | Weighted Average: 23.67 | Consensus: Mid-Late 1st

26. John Jenkins, DT, Georgia | High: 25 | Low: 31 | Weighted Average: 28.00 | Consensus: Late 1st/Early 2nd

27. Tyler Eifert, TE, Notre Dame | High: 22 | Low: 39 | Weighted Average: 29.33 | Consensus: Late 1st/Early 2nd

28. Kevin Minter, ILB, LSU | High: 20 | Low: 36 | Weighted Average: 30.00 | Consensus: Late 1st/Early 2nd

29. Alex Okafor, DE, Texas | High: 25 | Low: 39 | Weighted Average: 33 | Consensus: Late 1st/Early 2nd

30. Desmond Trufant, CB, Washington | High: 15 | Low: 55 | Weighted Average: 34.67 | Consensus: Late 1st/Early 2nd

31. Xavier Rhodes, CB, Florida St. | High: 23 | Low: 46 | Weighted Average: 35.67 | Consensus: Late 1st/Early 2nd

32. Cordarrelle Patterson, WR, Tennessee | High: 20 | Low: 65 | Weighted Average: 36.00 | Consensus: Late 1st/Mid 2nd

33. Johnathan Banks, CB, Mississippi | High: 25 | Low: 52 | Weighted Average: 37.67 | Consensus: Late 1st/Early 2nd

34. Eric Reid, FS, LSU | High: 31 | Low: 50 | Weighted Average: 39.33 | Consensus: Late 1st/Early 2nd

35. DJ Fluker, OT, Alabama | High: 21 | Low: 70 | Weighted Average: 40.00 | Consensus: Late 1st/Mid 2nd

36. DeAndre Hopkins, WR, Clemson | High: 35 | Low: 51 | Weighted Average: 40.33 | Consensus: Early-Mid 2nd

37. Tavon Austin, WR, West Virginia | High: 36 | Low: 47 | Weighted Average: 40.33 | Consensus: Early-Mid 2nd

38. Kawaan Short, DT, Purdue | High: 37 | Low: 46 | Weighted Average: 41.67 | Consensus: Early-Mid 2nd

39. Giovani Bernard, RB, North Carolina | High: 21 | Low: 59 | Weighted Average: 41.67 | Consensus: Mid 1st/Mid 2nd

40. Matt Elam, SS, Florida | High: 38 | Low: 45 | Weighted Average: 42.00 | Consensus: Early-Mid 2nd

41. Terrance Williams, WR, Baylor | High: 33 | Low: 53 | Weighted Average: 43.67 | Consensus: Early-Mid 2nd

42. Logan Ryan, CB, Rutgers | High: 29 | Low: 54 | Weighted Average: 45.00 | Consensus: Early-Mid 2nd

43. Barrett Jones, C, Alabama | High: 30 | Low: 55 | Weighted Average: 45.67 | Consensus: Early-Mid 2nd

44. Tyler Wilson, QB, Arkansas | High: 43 | Low: 50 | Weighted Average: 45.67 | Consensus: Early-Mid 2nd

45. Eddie Lacy, RB, Alabama | High: 36 | Low: 54 | Weighted Average: 46.00 | Consensus: Late 1st/Mid 2nd

46. Mike Glennon, QB, North Carolina St. | High: 30 | Low: 68 | Weighted Average: 46.33 | Consensus: Early-Mid 2nd

47. Arthur Brown, OLB, Kansas St. | High: 32 | Low: 63 | Weighted Average: 47.33 | Consensus: Early-Mid 2nd

48. Justin Hunter, WR, Tennessee | High: 40 | Low: 67 | Weighted Average: 49.67 | Consensus: Mid 2nd

49. Larry Warford, OG, Kentucky | High: 32 | Low: 69 | Weighted Average 50.67 | Consensus: Early-Late 2nd

50. Ryan Nassib, QB, Syracuse | High: 49 | Low: 54 | Weighted Average: 50.67 | Consensus: Mid 2nd

51. Sylvester Williams, DT, North Carolina | High: 28 | Low: 92 | Weighted Average: 51.00 | Consensus: Early 2nd/Early 3rd

52. Jordan Poyer, CB, Oregon St. | High: 40 | Low: 72 | Weighted Average: 51.33 | Consensus: Mid 2nd/Early 3rd

53. Datone Jones, DE, UCLA | High: 21 | Low: 88 | Weighted Average: 55.33 | Consensus: Late 1st/Early 3rd

54. Oday Aboushi, OT, Virginia | High: 44 | Low: 72 | Weighted Average: 55.67 | Consensus: Mid 2nd/Early 3rd

55. Robert Woods, WR, USC | High: 41 | Low: 77 | Weighted Average: 55.67 | Consensus: Mid 2nd/Early 3rd

56. Margus Hunt, DE, SMU | High: 46 | Low: 74 | Weighted Average: 59.67 | Consensus: Mid 2nd/Early 3rd

57. Kyle Long, OT, Oregon | High: 48 | Low: 77 | Weighted Average: 60.00 | Consensus: Mid 2nd/Early 3rd

58. Montee Ball, RB, Wisconsin | High: 50 | Low: 74 | Weighted Average: 60.00 | Consensus: Mid 2nd/Early 3rd

59. Dallas Thomas, OT, Tennessee | High: 57 | Low: 65 | Weighted Average: 60.00 | Consensus: Late 2nd/Early 3rd

60. Travis Frederick, C, Wisconsin | High: 60 | Low: 67 | Weighted Average: 62.67 | Consensus: Late 2nd/Early 3rd

61. Tank Carradine, DE, Florida St. | High: 43 | Low: 95 | Weighted Average: 63.67 | Consensus: Mid 2nd/Mid 3rd

62. Robert Alford, CB, Southeastern Louisiana | High: 44 | Low: 80 | Weighted Average: 65.67 | Consensus: Mid 2nd/Mid 3rd

63. Khaseem Greene, OLB, Rutgers | High: 58 | Low: 84 | Weighted Average: 67.00 | Consensus: Late 2nd/Mid 3rd

64 Tyler Bray, QB, Tennessee | High: 62 | Low: 81 | Weighted Average: 68.33 | Consensus: Early-Mid 3rd

65. Andre Ellington, RB, Clemson | High: 57 | Low: 78 | Weighted Average: 69.33 | Consensus: Early-Mid 3rd

66. EJ Manuel, QB, Florida St. | High: 62 | Low: 82 | Weighted Average: 73.33 | Consensus: Early-Mid 3rd

67. Gavin Escobar, TE, San Diego St. | High: 40 | Low: 100 | Weighted Average: 73.67 | Consensus: Late 2nd/Late 3rd

68. Jamar Taylor, CB, Boise St. | High: 60 | Low: 83 | Weighted Average: 75.00 | Consensus: Early-Mid 3rd

69. Blidi Wreh-Wilson, CB, Connecticut | High: 61 | Low: 105 | Weighted Average: 75.67 | Consensus: Late 2nd/Late 3rd

70. Will Davis, CB, Utah St. | High: 56 | Low: 97 | Weighted Average: 77.00 | Consensus: Early-Late 3rd

71. Bennie Logan, DT, LSU | High: 41 | Low: 133 | Weighted Average: 77.33 | Consensus: Mid 2nd/Late 3rd

72. David Amerson, CB, North Carolina St. | High: 64 | Low: 99 | Weighted Average: 77.67 | Consensus: Early-Late 3rd

73. Phillip Thomas, FS, Fresno St. | High: 66 | Low: 100 | Weighted Average: 79.00 | Consensus: Mid 3rd/Early 4th

74. Quinton Patton, WR, Louisiana Tech | High: 56 | Low: 101 | Weighted Average: 80.67 | Consensus: Early-Late 3rd

75. TJ McDonald, FS, USC | High: 63 | Low: 109 | Weighted Average: 83.33 | Consensus: Early-Late 3rd

76. Da'Rick Rogers, WR, Tennessee Tech | High: 69 | Low: 110 | Weighted Average: 85.33 | Consensus: Early 3rd/Early 4th

77. Jordan Reed, TE, Florida | High: 80 | Low: 93 | Weighted Average: 87.33 | Consensus: Mid-Late 3rd

78. Stepfan Taylor, RB, Stanford | High: 67 | Low: 122 | Weighted Average: 87.67 | Consensus: Early 3rd/Early 4th

79. Brian Winters, OT, Kent St. | High: 69 | Low: 112 | Weighted Average: 88.00 | Consensus: Mid 3rd/Mid 4th

80. Brandon Williams, DT, Missouri Southern St. | High: 70 | Low: 127 | Weighted Average: 89.33 | Consensus: Mid 3rd/Mid 4th

81. Khaled Holmes, C, USC | High: 63 | Low: 130 | Weighted Average: 89.33 | Consensus: Mid 3rd/Mid 4th

82. Malliciah Goodman, DE, Clemson | High: 72 | Low: 111 | Weighted Average: 90.67 | Consensus: Mid 3rd/Mid 4th

83. Brennan Williams, OT, North Carolina | High: 64 | Low: 121 | Weighted Average: 91.00 | Consensus: Mid 3rd/Mid 4th

84. Akeem Spence, DT, Illinois | High: 75 | Low: 104 | Weighted Average: 91.33 | Consensus: Mid 3rd/Early 4th

85. Aaron Dobson, WR, Marshall | High: 48 | Low: 149 | Weighted Average: 92.33 | Consensus: Early 3rd/Mid 4th

86. Marcus Wheaton, WR, Oregon St. | High: 53 | Low: 119 | Weighted Average: 92.67 | Consensus: Late 2nd/Mid 4th

87. Travis Kelce, TE, Cincinnati | High: 64 | Low: 125 | Weighted Average: 95.00 | Consensus: Early 3rd/Early 4th

88. Justin Pugh, OT, Syracuse | High: 79 | Low: 117 | Weighted Average: 95.67 | Consensus: Mid 3rd/Mid 4th

89. Tony Jefferson, FS, Oklahoma | High: 71 | Low: 125 | Weighted Average: 96.33 | Consensus: Mid 3rd/Mid 4th

90. Joseph Randle, RB, Oklahoma St. | High: 85 | Low: 104 | Weighted Average: 96.33 | Consensus: Late 3rd/Mid 4th

91. Landry Jones, QB, Oklahoma | High: 89 | Low: 106 | Weighted Average: 96.33 | Consensus: Early-Mid 4th

92. Jawan Jamison, RB, Rutgers | High: 34 | Low: 146 | Weighted Average: 96.67 | Consensus: Mid 2nd/Late 4th

93. John Simon, DE, Ohio St. | High: 84 | Low: 123 | Weighted Average: 97.00 | Consensus: Mid 3rd/Mid 4th

94. Jonathan Cyprien, SS, Florida International | High: 47 | Low: 125 | Weighted Average: 97.33 | Consensus: Late 2nd/Mid 4th

95. Brandon Jenkins, OLB, Florida St. | High: 76 | Low: 118 | Weighted Average: 97.33 | Consensus: Mid 3rd/Mid 4th

96. Cobi Hamilton, WR, Arkansas | High: 83 | Low: 115 | Weighted Average: 97.67 | Consensus: Early-Mid 4th

97. Bacarri Rambo, FS, Georgia | High: 86 | Low: 107 | Weighted Average: 99.67 | Consensus: Late 3rd/Mid 4th

98. Marquise Goodwin, WR, Texas | High: 90 | Low: 122 | Weighted Average: 100.67 | Consensus: Late 3rd/Mid 4th

99. Sean Porter, OLB, Texas A&M | High: 68 | Low: 131 | Weighted Average: 102.33 | Consensus: Mid 3rd/Late 4th

100. Le'Veon Bell, RB, Michigan St. | High: 79 | Low: 134 | Weighted Average: 103.33 | Consensus: Late 3rd/Mid 4th

101. Darius Slay, CB, Mississippi St. | High: 75 | Low: <150 | Weighted Average: 104.33 | Consensus: Mid 3rd/Late 4th

102. Chase Thomas, OLB, Stanford | High: 73 | Low: 143 | Weighted Average: 106.00 | Consensus: Late 3rd/Late 4th

103. Shawn Williams, SS, Georgia | High: 99 | Low: 117 | Weighted Average: 106.33 | Consensus: Early-Late 4th

104. DJ Swearinger, FS, South Carolina | High: 60 | Low: 137 | Weighted Average: 108.67 | Consensus: Early 3rd/Late 4th

105. Leon McFadden, CB, San Diego St. | High: 86 | Low: 135 | Weighted Average: 110.00 | Consensus: Early-Late 4th

106. Christine Michael, RB, Texas A&M | High: 76 | Low: <150 | Weighted Average: 111.67 | Consensus: Late 3rd/Late 4th

107. Dion Sims, TE, Michigan St. | High: 85 | Low: 132 | Weighted Average: 111.67 | Consensus: Late 3rd/Late 4th

108. B.W. Webb, CB, William & Mary | High: 90 | Low: 135 | Weighted Average: 112.00 | Consensus: Early-Late 4th

109. Jamie Collins, OLB, Southern Miss | High: 96 | Low: 135 | Weighted Average: 112.00 | Consensus: Early-Late 4th

110. Chris Faulk, OT, LSU | High: 79 | Low: <150 | Weighted Average: 112.67 | Consensus: Late 3rd/Late 4th

111. Johnathan Franklin, RB, UCLA | High: 94 | Low: 142 | Weighted Average: 113.33 | Consensus: Late 3rd/Late 4th

112. Gerald Hodges, OLB, Penn St. | High: 94 | Low: 135 | Weighted Average: 114.33 | Consensus: Late 3rd/Late 4th

113. Jordan Mills, OT, Louisiana Tech | High: 98 | Low: <150 | Weighted Average: 116.67 | Consensus: Early 4th/Mid 5th

114. Menelik Watson, OT, Florida St. | High: 92 | Low: <150 | Weighted Average: 117.33 | Consensus: Early 4th/Mid 5th

115. Jon Bostic, ILB, Florida | High: 102 | Low: 138 | Weighted Average: 117.67 | Consensus: Mid 4th/Early 5th

116. Zaviar Gooden, OLB, Missouri | High: 67 | Low: <150 | Weighted Average: 119.00 | Consensus: Early 4th/Late 5th

117. Montori Hughes, DT, Tennessee Martin | High: 66 | Low: <150 | Weighted Average: 120.00 | Consensus: Early 4th/Mid 5th

118. Kevin Reddick, ILB, North Carolina | High: 99 | Low: 137 | Weighted Average: 120.00 | Consensus: Mid 4th/Early 5th

119. Zac Dysert, QB, Miami-Ohio | High: 86 | Low: 142 | Weighted Average: 120.33 | Early 3rd/Late 4th

120. Marcus Lattimore, RB, South Carolina | High: 88 | Low: <150 | Weighted Average: 121.33 | Consensus: Late 3rd/Late 5th

Edited by TuggIe2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

You think Geno Smith is the 11th best player in this draft? He is pathetic. I would rather have Luke McCown

This isn't what I think. It's the consensus. He's almost universally ranked at 13-14, which, combined with the variation in the rankings of others, puts him in the 11 spot.

If I wasn't objective, my rankings would be all over the place. I have very specific opinons on players.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This isn't what I think. It's the consensus. He's almost universally ranked at 13-14, which, combined with the variation in the rankings of others, puts him in the 11 spot.

If I wasn't objective, my rankings would be all over the place. I have very specific opinons on players.

oh ok... I was going to say because I usually agree with things you post. Do u think he is good? Edited by RYNE15
Link to comment
Share on other sites

oh ok... I was going to say because I usually agree with things you post. Do u think he is good?

I honestly don't like any of the QBs in this draft too much. Barkley is the closest thing to a "sure" thing, and even he doesn't wow me. Manuel is alright, as is Nassib. But it's just really subpar compared to the last couple drafts.

I think Geno Smith is good, sure. But I don't think he's going to be great.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dude....what's your address, I'ma send you some cash....I feel like you should be paid to for taking time to do this lmao

All jokes aside, the beauty of it is that merging some legitimate mocks into a form like this is a pretty good balance of subjective talent analysis, team need, and objectivity. Gives you an idea of who truly may go where and who may still be around when we pick.

Interesting to see the first halfback going around 45, Gives me some hope we can get more food for our dollar in the 3rd or 4th round

So much better than say, a true Big Board that has Chance Womack, for instance, # 4, but has him actually getting drafted somewhere around 30

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I honestly don't like any of the QBs in this draft too much. Barkley is the closest thing to a "sure" thing, and even he doesn't wow me. Manuel is alright, as is Nassib. But it's just really subpar compared to the last couple drafts.

I think Geno Smith is good, sure. But I don't think he's going to be great.

I think they are awful including barkley. Barkley is the 2nd coming of Jimmy Clausen. I never liked him even when the "experts" had him ranked so high a while back
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dude....what's your address, I'ma send you some cash....I feel like you should be paid to for taking time to do this lmao

All jokes aside, the beauty of it is that merging some legitimate mocks into a form like this is a pretty good balance of subjective talent analysis, team need, and objectivity. Gives you an idea of who truly may go where and who may still be around when we pick.

Interesting to see the first halfback going around 45, Gives me some hope we can get more food for our dollar in the 3rd or 4th round

So much better than say, a true Big Board that has Chance Womack, for instance, # 4, but has him actually getting drafted somewhere around 30

Yeah, the only negative is that there are several teams ahead of us who need a RB...but he could very, very easily be there when we're picking. I still would rather have a guard (Warford) or DT/DE though. That's why the trade back makes sense; our positions of need will be there if we trade back - it's more a matter of successfully trading back in the first place. The Rams are a likely partner.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dude....what's your address, I'ma send you some cash....I feel like you should be paid to for taking time to do this lmao

All jokes aside, the beauty of it is that merging some legitimate mocks into a form like this is a pretty good balance of subjective talent analysis, team need, and objectivity. Gives you an idea of who truly may go where and who may still be around when we pick.

Interesting to see the first halfback going around 45, Gives me some hope we can get more food for our dollar in the 3rd or 4th round

So much better than say, a true Big Board that has Chance Womack, for instance, # 4, but has him actually getting drafted somewhere around 30

warmack getting drafted at 30? You are on drugs he may be the best player in the draft. But he is a guard. I guarantee u he doesnt fall past dallas. But he wont even make it that far down
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I applaud the effort for this Big Board.

Trufant @ #30???

This board had 2 OG's rated much much higher.

Now ask yourself this.

Your team is on the Clock in the first round.

You are going to choose an OG over probably the best CB in

this years draft class?

the First round is for your exceptional and key play makers.

Every team wants Warmack, and why wouldnt they?

But to wave off a Top CB, WR,LT, QB for a guard. NO.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I applaud the effort for this Big Board.

Trufant @ #30???

This board had 2 OG's rated much much higher.

Now ask yourself this.

Your team is on the Clock in the first round.

You are going to choose an OG over probably the best CB in

this years draft class?

the First round is for your exceptional and key play makers.

Every team wants Warmack, and why wouldnt they?

But to wave off a Top CB, WR,LT, QB for a guard. NO.

Did you read the post? This isn't my opinion. This is basically the average stock the intelligent draft sites put into certain players, averaged out and put into one place for convenience sake. I had pretty much no part in choosing where guys went. This is just a realistic outlook of where most guys are ranked.

EDIT: And yeah, I'd take Warmack over Trufant (though optimally, I'd take Warford after trading down). Sue me. :P

Edited by TuggIe2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

because he isnt any good. If he was so good dont u think the chiefs would want him?

Yes and I bet they do. I think he will be the first pick. Cam was mocked at the back half of round one this time in 2011.

Just because he isn't a can't Andrew Luck type prospect doesn't mean he isn't a good prospect.

Edited by Cam Topdrew Bottom
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

×
×
  • Create New...