Jump to content

More Opinions On Smithism


peoriabird
 Share

Recommended Posts

Jeff Schultz

Falcons, Smith going to amusing extremes to get an edge

5:42 pm September 5, 2012, by Jeff Schultz

Falcons coach Mike Smith is being tighter than ever with information. (Curtis Compton/AJC)

FLOWERY BRANCH – If NFL coaches aren’t collectively the most paranoid group of individuals on Earth, it’s only because somebody is counting the building on the other side of the barbed-wire fence, where Cheswick, Martini and R.P. McMurphy are betting cigarettes in a poker game.

I’m not sure when this level of Patton-vs.-Rommel secrecy began. But I can confirm from my days in San Francisco that Bill Walsh’s eyes would morph into fireballs at practice any time a reporter took notes that might be referencing Joe Montana throwing to Jerry Rice (because, well, who knew)?

I bring this up because as the Falcons approach their season opener Sunday in Kansas City, coach Mike Smith is taking secrecy to amusing levels. He was asked the other day about his starting right guard and cornerback. His response: “I’m not going to discuss it because I’m not going to give a competitive advantage to our opponent.”

He was asked about his punt returner: “I can’t tell you who our punt returner is going to be, either.”

He was asked about the backup quarterback: “I would not answer that question based on giving someone a competitive advantage.”

OK, seriously? The Chiefs are panicking in defensive meeting rooms, not having finality over the Falcons’ backup situation? The state secret of Luke McCown or Dominique Davis gives the Falcons a distinct advantage?

“Yes,” Smith reaffirmed Wednesday.

He will play you in “Stratego” and make you beg for mercy.

I informed Smith on Wednesday that, for AJC competitive reasons, I couldn’t tell him if I would be covering Sunday’s game.

“Touche,” he said, smiling, and held out a hand for a fist bump.

The Falcons seem to have become an increasingly secretive organization. That’s fine. It doesn’t differentiate them much from most NFL teams. But Smith should understand that the reason the team has had a string of one-and-done appearances has nothing to do with the other team not knowing who’s going to return punts.

All of those minute, perceived strategy “edges” go out the window when a 300-pound left tackle is getting Winnebagoed by a pass rusher. Or a cornerback blows his transmission in pass coverage. Or the quarterback is turning the ball over. And that’s why the Falcons have failed to win playoff games.

If Smith is being less forthcoming with information — and certainly media access in this training camp was tighter than in previous years — it’s no wonder. The pressure on him has been ratcheted up. The Falcons being just a very good regular-season team doesn’t satisfy the masses any more, least of all Arthur Blank. So Smith is seeking any edge he can get. But what’s a real edge and what’s imagined?

Smith doesn’t believe he’s any tighter now than before. “There’s certain information at certain times of the year that may be more important to not talk about,” he said. “Later in the year, when there’s more film and people have time to evaluate you, it’s probably not that big of a deal.”

He also now claims the No. 2 quarterback situation hasn’t been settled, though he says his mindset would be the same even if it had been.

These are not to be confused with those areas that most believe determine winners of football games.

“Running, tackling and blocking,” Falcons running back Michael Turner said.

I felt compelled to ask Turner if he was starting. He laughed.

“I don’t know. They haven’t announced the starters yet. I guess we’ll know when they have the introductions.”

I asked center Todd McClure. “Talk to the gray-haired man,” he said.

I asked Ryan. “As far as I know,” he said. (Broke him.)

Projections for the Falcons are all over the board. Some see Julio Jones, new coordinators, new philosophies and think, “Super Bowl.” But there’s emotional scar tissue from the past two seasons. Locally, this team seems to be flying under the radar.

“I guess everyone’s sitting back and waiting,” Turner said, “and if we’re fortunate enough to make the playoffs, they’ll see what happens then. That doesn’t bother us. We’ve got to make people believe. Hopefully we’ll get back there and make some noise when we get there.”

In a few days, there won’t be any secrets. We’ll know what really matters.

By Jeff Schultz

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Best article on the Falcons all year...MS better be desperate. Even though I think all the secrecy is stupid.

The Falcons seem to have become an increasingly secretive organization. That’s fine. It doesn’t differentiate them much from most NFL teams. But Smith should understand that the reason the team has had a string of one-and-done appearances has nothing to do with the other team not knowing who’s going to return punts.

All of those minute, perceived strategy “edges” go out the window when a 300-pound left tackle is getting Winnebagoed by a pass rusher. Or a cornerback blows his transmission in pass coverage. Or the quarterback is turning the ball over. And that’s why the Falcons have failed to win playoff games.

If Smith is being less forthcoming with information — and certainly media access in this training camp was tighter than in previous years — it’s no wonder. The pressure on him has been ratcheted up. The Falcons being just a very good regular-season team doesn’t satisfy the masses any more, least of all Arthur Blank. So Smith is seeking any edge he can get. But what’s a real edge and what’s imagined?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If I were a HC in the NFL , reporters would not be allowed in unti

1 hour after practice.

Playeres would be forbidden to discuss anything fooball related on

any social network.

By Gawd this is NFL Football and every sunday is all out War.

Save the chitty chat for the off season, or go play elsewhere.

I would be a total dictator and my coaching staff would be your so called "Players Coaches"

DUNTA! DID YOU JUST WIFF ON AN INT? 30 LAPS.

WHITE! DID YOU JUST TWITTER? YOUR BUNKING WITH FOSS TONIGHT!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

guy seems a bit miffed to me. poking smith with a few jabs is all he's doing. maybe smith is under a little bit more heat and rightly so after our playoff debacles. we need to play mightier when we are up against the likes of the saints, giants and upper echelon teams. I firmly believe the biggest changes are the coordinators which will go a long ways in breaking the old "play not to lose" mentality. smith better hope so for his sake. if smith was the one who is at fault for the ultra conservative schemes then he will certainly deserve to be fired if it continues this year.

I love smitty. I hope he lets our coordinators implement and adjust to their styles. but this article was really just schultz's way of blowing off steam of not knowing who the starters are. in smittys eyes, the miniscule advantage we have over the other team is nonetheless an advantage...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Since this will become a repeat topic, what was the story where a TV channel did an interview before a Superbowl, and the team was practicing a toss run in background and the opposing coach saw it and knew they had not run a toss run all season so they prepared their D for it. I think they stopped them on a key play. I saw a tv blurb on NFL channel one day with the coach saying he saw that, and I think it was Jimmy Johnson with cowboys, but I can't remember.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

guy seems a bit miffed to me. poking smith with a few jabs is all he's doing. maybe smith is under a little bit more heat and rightly so after our playoff debacles. we need to play mightier when we are up against the likes of the saints, giants and upper echelon teams. I firmly believe the biggest changes are the coordinators which will go a long ways in breaking the old "play not to lose" mentality. smith better hope so for his sake. if smith was the one who is at fault for the ultra conservative schemes then he will certainly deserve to be fired if it continues this year.

I love smitty. I hope he lets our coordinators implement and adjust to their styles. but this article was really just schultz's way of blowing off steam of not knowing who the starters are. in smittys eyes, the miniscule advantage we have over the other team is nonetheless an advantage...

The Falcons seem to have become an increasingly secretive organization. That’s fine. It doesn’t differentiate them much from most NFL teams. But Smith should understand that the reason the team has had a string of one-and-done appearances has nothing to do with the other team not knowing who’s going to return punts.

All of those minute, perceived strategy “edges” go out the window when a 300-pound left tackle is getting Winnebagoed by a pass rusher. Or a cornerback blows his transmission in pass coverage. Or the quarterback is turning the ball over. And that’s why the Falcons have failed to win playoff games.

If Smith is being less forthcoming with information — and certainly media access in this training camp was tighter than in previous years — it’s no wonder. The pressure on him has been ratcheted up. The Falcons being just a very good regular-season team doesn’t satisfy the masses any more, least of all Arthur Blank. So Smith is seeking any edge he can get. But what’s a real edge and what’s imagined?

By Jeff Schultz

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

×
×
  • Create New...