Jump to content

Crashing the Tea Party--interesting article on the movement.


Recommended Posts

Crashing the Tea Party

By DAVID E. CAMPBELL and ROBERT D. PUTNAM

GIVEN how much sway the Tea Party has among Republicans in Congress and those seeking the Republican presidential nomination, one might think the Tea Party is redefining mainstream American politics.

But in fact the Tea Party is increasingly swimming against the tide of public opinion: among most Americans, even before the furor over the debt limit, its brand was becoming toxic. To embrace the Tea Party carries great political risk for Republicans, but perhaps not for the reason you might think.

Polls show that disapproval of the Tea Party is climbing. In April 2010, a New York Times/CBS News survey found that 18 percent of Americans had an unfavorable opinion of it, 21 percent had a favorable opinion and 46 percent had not heard enough. Now, 14 months later, Tea Party supporters have slipped to 20 percent, while their opponents have more than doubled, to 40 percent.

Of course, politicians of all stripes are not faring well among the public these days. But in data we have recently collected, the Tea Party ranks lower than any of the 23 other groups we asked about — lower than both Republicans and Democrats. It is even less popular than much maligned groups like “atheists” and “Muslims.” Interestingly, one group that approaches it in unpopularity is the Christian Right.

The strange thing is that over the last five years, Americans have moved in an economically conservative direction: they are more likely to favor smaller government, to oppose redistribution of income and to favor private charities over government to aid the poor. While none of these opinions are held by a majority of Americans, the trends would seem to favor the Tea Party. So why are its negatives so high? To find out, we need to examine what kinds of people actually support it.

Beginning in 2006 we interviewed a representative sample of 3,000 Americans as part of our continuing research into national political attitudes, and we returned to interview many of the same people again this summer. As a result, we can look at what people told us, long before there was a Tea Party, to predict who would become a Tea Party supporter five years later. We can also account for multiple influences simultaneously — isolating the impact of one factor while holding others constant.

Our analysis casts doubt on the Tea Party’s “origin story.” Early on, Tea Partiers were often described as nonpartisan political neophytes. Actually, the Tea Party’s supporters today were highly partisan Republicans long before the Tea Party was born, and were more likely than others to have contacted government officials. In fact, past Republican affiliation is the single strongest predictor of Tea Party support today.

What’s more, contrary to some accounts, the Tea Party is not a creature of the Great Recession. Many Americans have suffered in the last four years, but they are no more likely than anyone else to support the Tea Party. And while the public image of the Tea Party focuses on a desire to shrink government, concern over big government is hardly the only or even the most important predictor of Tea Party support among voters.

So what do Tea Partiers have in common? They are overwhelmingly white, but even compared to other white Republicans, they had a low regard for immigrants and blacks long before Barack Obama was president, and they still do.

More important, they were disproportionately social conservatives in 2006 — opposing abortion, for example — and still are today. Next to being a Republican, the strongest predictor of being a Tea Party supporter today was a desire, back in 2006, to see religion play a prominent role in politics. And Tea Partiers continue to hold these views: they seek “deeply religious” elected officials, approve of religious leaders’ engaging in politics and want religion brought into political debates. The Tea Party’s generals may say their overriding concern is a smaller government, but not their rank and file, who are more concerned about putting God in government.

This inclination among the Tea Party faithful to mix religion and politics explains their support for Representative Michele Bachmann of Minnesota and Gov. Rick Perry of Texas. Their appeal to Tea Partiers lies less in what they say about the budget or taxes, and more in their overt use of religious language and imagery, including Mrs. Bachmann’s lengthy prayers at campaign stops and Mr. Perry’s prayer rally in Houston.

Yet it is precisely this infusion of religion into politics that most Americans increasingly oppose. While over the last five years Americans have become slightly more conservative economically, they have swung even further in opposition to mingling religion and politics. It thus makes sense that the Tea Party ranks alongside the Christian Right in unpopularity.

On everything but the size of government, Tea Party supporters are increasingly out of step with most Americans, even many Republicans. Indeed, at the opposite end of the ideological spectrum, today’s Tea Party parallels the anti-Vietnam War movement which rallied behind George S. McGovern in 1972. The McGovernite activists brought energy, but also stridency, to the Democratic Party — repelling moderate voters and damaging the Democratic brand for a generation. By embracing the Tea Party, Republicans risk repeating history.

David E. Campbell, an associate professor of political science at Notre Dame, and Robert D. Putnam, a professor of public policy at Harvard, are the authors of “American Grace: How Religion Divides and Unites Us.”

Link to post
Share on other sites

The GOP correctly saw the Tea Party as a threat to its institution, and moved quickly to hijack it. If you go back in time to look at the speakers at the first Tea Party conventions then versus the speakers now, they are vastly different groups of people.

Agree. The minute I saw the plant that is Sarah Palin latch onto to them I thought the same thing.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Do tea party supporters still believe that they represent middle America? But to be fair what happened to middle America anyway? To an outsider like me it seems that middle America is silent.

There is no such thing as middle America. It's a fictitious constituent conjured up by politicians to make people believe they are in fact middle America. When you actually drill down and poll these people, they don't believe in the things these politicians insinuate their belief of. Two opposing examples are small government and single payer healthcare. When you poll people about small government, on the surface it is viewed favorably. But when you actually start talking about cuts to specific programs, it is very controversial. Same with healthcare. It views favorably on the surface, but when you drill down on actual single payer systems, people don't want it.

Link to post
Share on other sites

There is no such thing as middle America. It's a fictitious constituent conjured up by politicians to make people believe they are in fact middle America. When you actually drill down and poll these people, they don't believe in the things these politicians insinuate their belief of. Two opposing examples are small government and single payer healthcare. When you poll people about small government, on the surface it is viewed favorably. But when you actually start talking about cuts to specific programs, it is very controversial. Same with healthcare. It views favorably on the surface, but when you drill down on actual single payer systems, people don't want it.

Actually, you just proved the point you're trying to refute. You're saying that Americans don't support either the small government policies of the right nor the big government policies of the left. People want moderate policies that fall between the two extremes--middle America. The fact is that most Americans are moderate in their political beliefs. Most people are in the middle, but get ignored because of structural and institutional factors that contribute to polarization in government.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Actually, you just proved the point you're trying to refute. You're saying that Americans don't support either the small government policies of the right nor the big government policies of the left. People want moderate policies that fall between the two extremes--middle America. The fact is that most Americans are moderate in their political beliefs. Most people are in the middle, but get ignored because of structural and institutional factors that contribute to polarization in government.

That is not "middle America." Middle America doesn't exist as it is described by our politicians and regurgitated by our media, and THAT is the point that I am trying to make.

It is in fact the middle of the political spectrum, but it is completely misportrayed by our politicians and media in order to make the polar sides of the political spectrum appear more mainstream.

Link to post
Share on other sites

It was pretty obvious the whole thing was GOP astro-turfing when dudes like Sean Hannity and Glenn Beck were endorsing the rallies/conventions and showing up at events.

And that was pretty early in the Tea Party "movement" (right after Obama took office). I'm not sure the GOP hijacked the Tea Party so much as they were the ones behind it from the start.

Link to post
Share on other sites

That is not "middle America." Middle America doesn't exist as it is described by our politicians and regurgitated by our media, and THAT is the point that I am trying to make.

It is in fact the middle of the political spectrum, but it is completely misportrayed by our politicians and media in order to make the polar sides of the political spectrum appear more mainstream.

Ah, I see what you're saying. I agree with everything you said.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...