Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

JC Falcon

Rate the 2008 Draft after 3 years

10 posts in this topic

Everyone claims you cannot really rate a draft until 3 years.

So objectively, how does the Falcons draft stack up that year and all time? It's probably not quite the Steeler's 1974 draft, but I think it will rate in the Top 10 if we get some playoff success.

Ryan #1.3 - Franchise QB 1st Rd

Baker #1.21 - Starting LT 1st (Can't call him franchise)

Lofton #2.6 - Franchise MLB 2d round

Jackson, Chevis #3.5 - First miss, though he did play in a few games for us.

Douglas, Harry #3.21 - Started some this year and played some as a rookie. Still finding his potential

DeCoud #3.35 - Starting FS, solid player.

James, Robert #5.3 - Never really cracked the field and was waived after 4 game suspension this season.

Biermann #5.19 - You probably don't plan your starting DE, ST ace, and even emergency kicker coming in the back end of the 5th round.

Brown, Thomas #6.6 - Horse collar IR'd and then lost his roster position battle the next year to another late round star, Jason Snelling.

Fontenot, Wilrey #7.5 - Final cut of 2008 roster, signed to Arizona PS. Cut after injury.

Zinger, Keith #7.25 - On the 2008 PS I think and made the 2009 team, was cut pre season this year.

All in all that has to be considered a great draft to get 5 starters plus a partial starter/slot receiver after 3 years. It has to help the analysis that those 6 guys have been winning games since the draft too.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Gotta give it an A just for finding your offensive and defensive anchors. However outside of Ryan, Lofton, Biermann, and Decoud the other guys might not get a second contract with the team.

It's much better looking right now than the 2009 draft which is looking kinda rough

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Gotta give it an A just for finding your offensive and defensive anchors. However outside of Ryan, Lofton, Biermann, and Decoud the other guys might not get a second contract with the team.

It's much better looking right now than the 2009 draft which is looking kinda rough

pretty much every team would love to get 4 long term starters from any draft. Even without one of them being the best young QB in the entire NFL.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ryan makes it an "A"

Remove him and it is a c+/B- as all the others are mostly average based on their peer groups in the NFL. I think the ultimate sleeper is DeCoud.

Baker--average

Lofton--above average

DeCoud--above average

Biermann--below average

Douglas--below average

Combined score (less Ryan): Average

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites