After last night's game, who would you keep, Nance or Smith?

[sharky]

I think they both had a nice game last and it would be pretty hard for me to say, but Smith has that speed and quickness you like to see, Nance has that power/speed but we already have that so I would have to go with Smith.

[The Falcon Jedi]

I think they both had a nice game last and it would be pretty hard for me to say, but Smith has that speed and quickness you like to see, Nance has that power/speed but we already have that so I would have to go with Smith.

If you think Antone Smith had a nice game then you need to be tested for drugs.

[MattIceRyanMVP2]

Cut Smith, Put Nance on the PS. I say keep Nance because of his speed and he's only 22. Give him a year to develop and he can be a real asset to the team.

[sharky]

If you think Antone Smith had a nice game then you need to be tested for drugs.

I only saw the first quarter and that's all I'm basing it on but I'll take your word. I'm just thinking about what we already have and what we might need in case Norwood go down again, that's all. Initially, I pulled for Nance anyways.

Edited September 3, 2010 by sharky

[phattywankenobi]

I don't know but check out Dimitri Nance's picture.

[lystrodom]

Nance has fantastic hands, and Smith has bricks for hands. They had Smith back "returning" kicks for a little bit. I don't think he actually caught any of them.

[sharky]

I don't know but check out Dimitri Nance's picture.

Are he and J Rock cousins or something? That hair.

[LADBABY]

Cut Smith, Put Nance on the PS. I say keep Nance because of his speed and he's only 22. Give him a year to develop and he can be a real asset to the team.

FYI.Smith is the speedy one and Nance is the thick set

4.6 forty guy.

[DaMeatTroughsEgo]

Smith has awful instincts and vision and his speed doesn't impress me. Keep Nance.

[LADBABY]

Nance has fantastic hands, and Smith has bricks for hands. They had Smith back "returning" kicks for a little bit. I don't think he actually caught any of them.

One he got between his legs and he could not even find it.

Strickland had to come over and down it.

[ballfan]

I think they both had a nice game last and it would be pretty hard for me to say, but Smith has that speed and quickness you like to see, Nance has that power/speed but we already have that so I would have to go with Smith.

I am really pulling for Nance. That little guy has some pop!

[Tandy]

Nance for me. First - he can bust some moves when he scores - and second - I really just like his running style.

I think he's a keeper.

[nobkowski]

Nance >>>Smith

Keep Nance.

[izwun]

Nance.

[Turner2endZone]

Nance. Smith definitly did not have a good game last night. Smith will be leaving the team.

[slick0ne]

Smith has awful instincts and vision and his speed doesn't impress me. Keep Nance.

That's the way I see it also.

[MattIceRyanMVP2]

It's a shame about Smith, Everyone was really high on him(including me), bummer it didn't work out the way everyone thought it would...

Edited September 3, 2010 by MattIceRyanMVP2

[Osiruz]

nance, smith had a horrible game.

[Knight of God]

I'd go with Nance and keep Smith on the PS.

[Goal Line D]

Nance hands down!

[lee sunset]

Nance

[iDash]

Cut them both

[BadMoonRising]

Nance > Smith.

but I wouldn;t keep ethier.

[sharky]

Cut them both

If we did that some team will get a good player and future starter, especially in Nance. The only reason I went with Smith is b/c we already have power/speed in Snelling / Turner, but if Norwood goes down we would need someone who can do the things that he does.

[BadMoonRising]

If we did that some team will get a good player and future starter, especially in Nance. The only reason I went with Smith is b/c we already have power/speed in Snelling / Turner, but if Norwood goes down we would need someone who can do the things that he does.

Can't agree young productive RB's are by far the easiest position to find, and the easiest to integrate into systems.