Jump to content

Please stop comparing Ryan to Manning !


Dr. Doom
 Share

Recommended Posts

nettts (5/10/2008)
FireDawg85 (5/10/2008)
nettts (5/10/2008)
tybarry (5/10/2008)
Hokies&Falcons (5/10/2008)
tybarry (5/10/2008)
I just can't believe the guys on here that are upset that we have a real quarterback now. Yeah Vick was exciting to watch, but he couldn't throw his way out of a wet paper bag. I think Ryan can and will do amazing things, but a lot of it is up to the coaching staff now.

During Vick's last season here, he was in the top 10 in numerous passing categories...

Yards per completion, touchdowns, touchdown to interception ratio, and total first downs etc...

Add all of that to being leading all QB's in rushing yards, yards per carry...

Say what you will about the guy off the field, but you're only making yourself look like a ****** by trying to minimize what he did on the field. It shows very very low football IQ...

As for Ryan, I have seen his work ethic compared to Manning's, which makes me very happy. That's probably as far as the comparison should go. I think Rya will become a good NFL Quarterback, not great, but good...

Show me some stats that prove he was a top 10 "passing Qb. But I guess this shood be expected from a guy with the name Hokies&Falcons. When are you guys going to let go of your love for Vick. How can you respect a guy who shows no respect for the sport, his team or the fans.

dude, you are an idiot. first of all your just happy to have a white guy playing qb for the falcons again, period.

thats all you care about. if we got brohm youd be doing the same thing. matt ryan did absolutely nothing to deserve being taken #3 overall, and will do nothing of any significance in the nfl, face it.

Here we go... WHITE/BLACK thing! Maybe we should have drafted Josh Johnson 

ahhhh... im white you idiot. and johnson in the 6th would have been a **** of a lot better value than ryan #3 overall. what a joke.

Man since you know talent SOOOOOO good, why don't you apply for ESPN? You could sweep Kiper off his feet. And also, IDIOT, I didnt say you were white or black, you were the one who said, "your just happy to have a white guy playing qb for the falcons again, period". Therefore, you made it about race, maybe you should be reported w/ those types of comments. Provoking a racism discussion

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Who cares about Payton Manning!!!!! It took him ten years to win a superbowl!  That was with the SAME coaches and gameplans!  He had great weapons!!! He had all the perfect senarios you want and still took him forever to win one!  Im not bashing the guy but come on with the love fest for him. 

If you have those parts in place like him and have a constant around you then you are bound to do well.  Some quarterbacks have 3 even 4 or more coordinators and numerous coaching changes handed to them.  Lets just hope whomever is our quarterback gets a solid foundation like Payton and he will be just fine.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dr. Doom (5/9/2008)
Look at Manning's college stat's, and look at Ryan's

Peyton Manning's

Passing | Rushing

Year G Comp Att Pct Int TD Yds | Att Yds Avg TD

1994 10 89 144 61.8 6 11 1141 | 21 -26 -1.2 1

1995 11 244 380 64.2 4 22 2954 | 41 6 0.1 5

1996 11 243 380 63.9 12 20 3287 | 42 -131 -3.1 3

1997 12 287 477 60.2 11 36 3819 | 49 -30 -0.6 3

+-----------------------------------------------------------------+

Totals 44 863 1381 62.5 33 89 11201 | 153 -181 -1.2 12

Matt Ryan's

Passing Stats
YEARTEAMCMPATTPCTYDSAVGTDLNGINTRAT
2004BC357149.33504.9232391.6
2005BC12119562.115147.88615135.7
2006BC26342761.629426.9157910126.4
2007BC38865459.345076.9317119127.0

Rushing Stats
YEARTEAMATTYDSAVGLNGTDFDFUMLOST
2004BC12-3-0.380000
2005BC37942.5125000
2006BC51-35-0.7154000
2007BC6820.0192000

you do the math, I provided the stats, Looks like Manning had a better college career to me.

People on this board actually compared Vick's pro career to Manning's career up until the incident last offseason. Some went as far as saying Vick was better than Manning. Why were there no calls to stop then?
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Abe (5/10/2008)
Who cares about Payton Manning!!!!! It took him ten years to win a superbowl!  That was with the SAME coaches and gameplans!  He had great weapons!!! He had all the perfect senarios you want and still took him forever to win one!  Im not bashing the guy but come on with the love fest for him. 

If you have those parts in place like him and have a constant around you then you are bound to do well.  Some quarterbacks have 3 even 4 or more coordinators and numerous coaching changes handed to them.  Lets just hope whomever is our quarterback gets a solid foundation like Payton and he will be just fine.

He had the same problem as Marino. No consistant running game and NO defense to support him.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Falcon Ace (5/10/2008)
Abe (5/10/2008)
Who cares about Payton Manning!!!!! It took him ten years to win a superbowl!  That was with the SAME coaches and gameplans!  He had great weapons!!! He had all the perfect senarios you want and still took him forever to win one!  Im not bashing the guy but come on with the love fest for him. 

If you have those parts in place like him and have a constant around you then you are bound to do well.  Some quarterbacks have 3 even 4 or more coordinators and numerous coaching changes handed to them.  Lets just hope whomever is our quarterback gets a solid foundation like Payton and he will be just fine.

He had the same problem as Marino. No consistant running game and NO defense to support him.

e.james won the rushing title 2 or 3 times in indy. the colts have always had a good rushing game.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

dan minnich (5/10/2008)
The Falcon Ace (5/10/2008)
Abe (5/10/2008)
Who cares about Payton Manning!!!!! It took him ten years to win a superbowl!  That was with the SAME coaches and gameplans!  He had great weapons!!! He had all the perfect senarios you want and still took him forever to win one!  Im not bashing the guy but come on with the love fest for him. 

If you have those parts in place like him and have a constant around you then you are bound to do well.  Some quarterbacks have 3 even 4 or more coordinators and numerous coaching changes handed to them.  Lets just hope whomever is our quarterback gets a solid foundation like Payton and he will be just fine.

He had the same problem as Marino. No consistant running game and NO defense to support him.

e.james won the rushing title 2 or 3 times in indy. the colts have always had a good rushing game.

Look at their defense.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Falcon Ace (5/10/2008)
dan minnich (5/10/2008)
The Falcon Ace (5/10/2008)
Abe (5/10/2008)
Who cares about Payton Manning!!!!! It took him ten years to win a superbowl!  That was with the SAME coaches and gameplans!  He had great weapons!!! He had all the perfect senarios you want and still took him forever to win one!  Im not bashing the guy but come on with the love fest for him. 

If you have those parts in place like him and have a constant around you then you are bound to do well.  Some quarterbacks have 3 even 4 or more coordinators and numerous coaching changes handed to them.  Lets just hope whomever is our quarterback gets a solid foundation like Payton and he will be just fine.

He had the same problem as Marino. No consistant running game and NO defense to support him.

e.james won the rushing title 2 or 3 times in indy. the colts have always had a good rushing game.

Look at their defense.

 

other than the last few year the defense wasnt all that great, i will give you that. there de now is good though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

dan minnich (5/10/2008)
The Falcon Ace (5/10/2008)
dan minnich (5/10/2008)
The Falcon Ace (5/10/2008)
Abe (5/10/2008)
Who cares about Payton Manning!!!!! It took him ten years to win a superbowl!  That was with the SAME coaches and gameplans!  He had great weapons!!! He had all the perfect senarios you want and still took him forever to win one!  Im not bashing the guy but come on with the love fest for him. 

If you have those parts in place like him and have a constant around you then you are bound to do well.  Some quarterbacks have 3 even 4 or more coordinators and numerous coaching changes handed to them.  Lets just hope whomever is our quarterback gets a solid foundation like Payton and he will be just fine.

He had the same problem as Marino. No consistant running game and NO defense to support him.

e.james won the rushing title 2 or 3 times in indy. the colts have always had a good rushing game.

Look at their defense.

 

other than the last few year the defense wasnt all that great, i will give you that. there de now is good though.

There defense was worthless until the later part of 2006. Bottom of the league worthless actually. In 2006 they allowed more points than our defense and was overall ranked one better than us(21).

In the season Manning broke the NFL records for TDs and Passer Rating in a season, the Colts defense was ranked 29th...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

×
×
  • Create New...