Jump to content

CFN ranks the Offensive guards


Recommended Posts

2008 NFL Draft - Ranking Offensive Guards

By Pete Fiutak


Posted Apr 12, 2008

CFN ranks the top 30 prospects with the deep sleeper and most overrated and underrated players.

2008 NFL Draft Position Rankings

The Offensive Guards

By Pete Fiutak

The Class Is ... Good, and it could be great if a few hit-or-miss players like Tennessee's Eric Young and Connecticut's Donald Thomas pan out. The key is versatility with several athletic guards able to play tackle, but there are few road grating power blockers.

The Best Value Pick Will Be ... Eric Tunney, Central Michigan

Most Underrated ... John Greco, Toledo

Most Overrated ... Eric Young, Tennessee

The Deep, Deep Sleeper Is ... Kerry Brown, Appalachian State


1. Branden Albert, OG/OT Virginia

While he's not D'Brickashaw Ferguson as far as a prospect, he has a lot in common with the former Virginia star. Albert is a great athlete who only cemented himself further as the top guard prospect in the draft with some nice off-season workouts. Even though he has the range and the moves to be a tackle, even on the left side, he could be a superstar if he stays inside. A killer run blocker who started from day one, he can be plugged into any NFL line and be a starter somewhere. It would be nice if he had a little seasoning and he's a bit tall (6-7) for a guard, but he has the potential to be a perennial Pro Bowler.

CFN Projection: Late First Round To Early Second Round

2. Chilo Rachal, OG USC

He could've used another year in school, leaving early due to family medical issues, but he's just fine as a guard prospect if he's allowed a little time to develop. He'll have problems against quicker linemen and isn't a great pass protector, but he has good size and nice power for the ground game. If he has to be nimble and has to get on the move in a finesse offense, he won't fit. Ask him to hit someone over and over again on a second half drive and he'll get the job done.

CFN Projection: Third Round

3. Roy Schuening, OG Oregon State

An excellent four-year starter for the Beavers, Schuening is excellent when he has to open a hole and get the ground game moving. If he has to get moving and if he has to pass protect on a regular basis, there will be problems. He's a strong player who'll be tough to leave on the bench and tougher to cut because of his toughness, durability and versatility, he spent some time at tackle, but he'll have find the right offense and the right style to be a steady NFL starter.

CFN Projection: Third Round

4. John Greco, OG/OT Toledo

If he's not the greatest MAC offensive lineman of all-time, he's in the team photo. A starter from day one to game 49, he's ridiculously durable, freakishly strong, and will work his tail off to get better. While he was an all-everything tackle for Toledo, he just doesn't have the quickness of the athleticism to be on the outside at the highest level. He could move to tackle from time to time, but he has the size, toughness, and make-up to shine as a guard if given the chance to grow into the job.

CFN Projection: Third Round

5. Eric Young OG Tennessee

There are a world of problems. He never played up to his talent level, hurt his leg last year and played in just eight games, and he isn't nearly as physical as he should've been on a consistent basis. Even so, he has too many tools not to be a starter at some point if only because he has more skill and talent than roughly 80% of current starting NFL guards. If he actually wants to be good, and if he plays for the right coach who can turn the switch on, he'll be the second best guard in the draft behind Branden Albert. That's a big if.

CFN Projection: Third Round

6. Donald Thomas, OG Connecticut

While he's not a huge inside presence, he's one of the better athletes among the guards and is one of the few who can get on the move. He's be a nice fit for a zone-blocking scheme and isn't bad in pass protection, but he's not going to beat anyone up and he needs a lot of seasoning. A total unknown, being discovered playing pickup basketball, he's a true rags-to-riches story who has a world of potential is someone has a little patience.

CFN Projection: Fifth Round


7. Mike McGlynn, OG/OT Pitt

A brutish run blocker who has been one of the most consistent players on an inconsistent Pitt team over the last three years, McGlynn did everything asked of him and played hurt when most would've been on the sidelines. The problem is his quickness; he doesn't have any. While he was a great tackle at the collegiate level, he could be a star at guard if allowed a while to develop. He'll have a long career on want-to, but there's a ceiling on what he can do.

CFN Projection: Fourth Round

8. Mackenzy Bernadeau, OG/OT Bentley

While he's not all that strong, at least not strong enough to overcome that fact that he went to Bentley, and he's coming off a knee injury, he's a big athlete who moves well and has worked his tail off to make himself into a pro prospect. Ideally a tackle with his tools, he's not an NFL tackle in talent. He'll make his money, if he can stick with a team, by being a good pass protector on the inside.

CFN Projection: Sixth Round

9. Robert Felton, OG/C Arkansas

One of the draft's most versatile guard prospects, able to step in at any position, especially center, he's a big, powerful blocker with the feet to grow into a pass protector on the outside if someone wants to develop him into a tackle. The problem is in the development. He needs coaching on his technique and he'll need to find one position and stick with it; it's probably not center at the pro level.

CFN Projection: Fourth Round

10. Andrew Crummey, OG Maryland

Very strong and very good for the running game, he's a limited plowhorse who can move the pile, but won't do much to get on the outside. While he's a good-sized 6-4 and 299 pounds, he's not the blot-out-the-sun type of guard most teams might like. Considering his lack of athleticism, he has to get bigger. Even with all his limits, he'll be a tough player to cut because he can be so good in a short running game.

CFN Projection: Sixth Round

11. Eric Tunney, OG Central Michigan

He's just not big enough. Checking in at 6-3 and 296 pounds, he simply isn't the big road grater most teams would like. He works his tail off and he's as tough as nails, but he needs to be in the right system to have any hope of being a regular player. However, even with his knee problems, he could stick if he's in a zone-blocking scheme.

CFN Projection: Fifth Round

12. Shawn Murphy, OG/OT Utah State

A former JUCO transfer, Murphy came to Utah State and was a solid starter for two years. He's a little old after spending three years on an LDS church mission and he still needs some serious fine-tuning on his skills and his technique. One of his big plusses is his versatility. At 6-3 and 320 pounds he could be a big tackle or a solid guard. While he won't do any one thing well, he could grow into a nice backup.

CFN Projection: Fifth Round

13. Chester Adams, OG/OT Georgia

He's versatile enough to play either tackle or guard, but he's not good enough to be a regular at either spot. He has the size, he has the strength, and he has the athleticism, but he doesn't always play up to his measurables. He was a good college player who earned enough respect to be a captain, but he didn't dominate like he should've.

CFN Projection: Fifth Round

14. Chris McDuffie, OG Clemson

Very big and very beefy, the 6-4, 329-pounder is surprisingly agile and very tough. He has had a variety of injuries he's been able to play through. He's not that great a blocker, and while he has a world of upside, he's a bit of a project. On size and toughness alone he should stick in the league for a little while.

CFN Projection: Sixth Round

15. Kerry Brown, OG Appalachian State

One of the most athletic and experienced guards in the draft, Brown started 49 games including 15 in each of the last three seasons. He's not the most physical of blockers, but he's fantastic at getting down the field and he can pull extremely well. While he was great against Michigan, there's still the knock of the competition level he faced and he wasn't always consistent.

CFN Projection: Sixth Round

16. Mike Fladell, OG/OT Rutgers

At 6-6 and 324 pounds he's a big, versatile pounder of a blocker able to play either guard or tackle. He's not going to do much on the move and he's not athletic enough to grow into a star, but he's really strong, really tough, and have good enough potential to be a serviceable pro.

CFN Projection: Seventh Round

17. Charles Manu, OG/OT Nevada

A still developing prospect who could pay off if he's given time, Manu started out as a defensive lineman and was moved all over the place later on the offensive line. Tough, and versatile enough to slip out to tackle if needed, he could be a jack-of-all-trades backup, but he's not skilled or athletic enough to be a starter.

CFN Projection: Seventh Round

18. Matt Spanos, OG/C USC

Able to play anywhere on the line, he's built like an NFL tackle but will be better suited for the inside. At 6-5 and 317 pounds, size isn't an issue, but he plays too tall for a guard. He could stand to get stronger, much stronger, and he has to be more physical, but his versatility makes him an interesting prospect.

CFN Projection: Free Agent

19. Adam Kraus, OG/C Michigan

His ability to play anywhere on the inside could make him a valuable backup, but he's not strong enough to be a regular. Size is a bit of an issue as he's not going to move much earth at 292 pounds, but he produced at the highest level for a few years. He would've been a must-have reserve but he had major problems in off-season workouts, especially at the East-West Shrine game.

CFN Projection: Free Agent

20. Matt Lindner, OG TCU

While he has the muscle and the strength, he's not big enough at just 284 pounds to be a regular starter. He didn't push too many people around at the college level and will struggle against the biggest tackles in the pros. Injuries have also been a problem. He's tough, but it doesn't mean much if he can't stay healthy.

CFN Projection: Free Agent


21. Hercules Satele, OG Hawaii

22. L.J. Anderson, OG UCF

23. Kirk Elder, OG Texas A&M

24. Shannon Tevaga, OG UCLA

25. Justin Britt, OG Alabama

26. James Lee, OG South Carolina State

27. James Blair, OG Western Michigan

28. Jason Boone, OG Utah

29. Ian-Yates Cunningham, OG Virginia

30. Derrick Morse, OG Miami

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Create New...