Intellectually Honest

Forum Members
  • Content count

    2,274
  • Joined

  • Last visited

About Intellectually Honest

  • Rank
    Starting Lineup

Recent Profile Visitors

2,904 profile views
  1. I never got the Saints hate. To me they are just another team. I just want the Falcons to win the Super Bowl. If they don't win it, I could care less who does. I think the Saints hate is more of a homer issue than a Falcon fan issue.
  2. I have been complaining about the Oline for years, especially the guards, and all I have been called is a hater and troll.
  3. I am glad Ryan turned it around this year. This year actually might be even more impressive than 2016 since he really doesn't have much of a running game helping him. I was really worried that 2016 was a fluke. I hope he keeps it up.
  4. I think that was true in past years. I am not sure it is true anymore.
  5. No one questions if the Falcons have some talent for SOME of their starters. Obviously they do. But they do have glaring holes and depth has always been the Achilles heel for this team. I don't buy into the hype of the Falcons beat up a lowly team or a team that has a lot of injuries, just like I don't get angry if they lose to a really good team and say the team stinks. Only when the Falcons lose to the worse of the worse does it hurt, or when the Falcons win against strong healthy teams before I buy into the hype. There are too many variables in winning or losing for me to be dramatic one way or the other.
  6. Julio jumps higher than Calvin. Calvin has the height advantage though. Go look at their draft workouts. While Calvin's vertical was good, Julio's was freakish.
  7. No. It just means you agree that they should be paid that high and I don't. "Fair market value" is just an opinion. It's just saying "this is what the other guys make, so you should make it also".
  8. I don't know about fair market. To me those guys are all over paid.
  9. I would let Freeman and Coleman walk. There is really no reason to pay top dollar to any RB. Even Gurley struggled with a bad Oline. In spite of the scoring, the Falcons have been terrible running the ball. The team would be better off using a low rounder to draft an RB or even getting a UDFA.
  10. Why in the fug is JJ running out of bounds?
  11. I think this accurately describes what the OP is saying Falcons= Jobber Rest of the NFL= Yokozuna
  12. You are actually agreeing with a point you are trying to argue against. ALL Olines age. You can even say all Olines are investments also. The point is not if the team invested in it, but when, and if that Oline is still as valuable as when it was initially invested in, whether it is FA or the draft. It would be asinine to believe that some player, regardless of position, is going to play at the same level in their early to mid 30s as they did in their mid 20s. Sure there are a few exceptions, but that is not the rule. Also it's not necessarily even FA either. It's when the Falcons got the player. Getting players nearing their late 20s or later is a bad investment for long term value. It's not just that they are old but banged up. Injuries stack over time. Also 9th best doesn't mean crap since Olines across the NFL are crap. It's a relative privation fallacy. It's the equavalent of saying you have the 9th least crappy Oline. Sure you want bang for your buck. The draft is more helpful since the money spent is lower by comparison. But if your team is like the Falcons, which refuses to trade down to gain draft capital, then they will just try to get in their opinion BPA, even if that means overlooking the Oline, or scraping the barrel from what is left. The problem is not just talent but the assumption that a talented player will stay talented. Fans for the most part just assume that what players on the roster will just continue to get better and all they need to do is fill in the gaps. It doesn't work that way. Even Alex Mack is old. He is still playing well but expect a decline in the next couple of years. I am surprised it hasn't occurred already.
  13. As far as I am concerned, you might as well stick a fork in his career. Not only are the injuries piling up, but their effects are stacking. It won't get easier. Combine that with the shelf life of a RB, and the physical demand it has on the body, it pretty much over for him. Devonta was a good RB. It's a shame. PS: The only kind of good news is, given the state of the running game this year, which is non-existant, it might not really matter.
  14. Ryan is not to blame, though Wilson would be an upgrade. I would say the defense needs to play better but a good chunk of them are backups and it would be an unrealistic expectation to believe they would be as good or close to as good as the starters were.
  15. All 4 of those teams are doing better than the Steelers. Why in the world do you think the Falcons would beat them to be a spoiler in the first place.