chifalc

Can’t speak for other people, but nope, I still think PFF is nothing special.

Seriously, how many players and coaches do the 2018 Browns have in common with the 2017 Bills and Dolphins? If you want to try to talk about matchup issues with the Browns, fair game, but all of these other things you mention really are irrelevant in context.

We aren’t playing ‘afc teams’ which is meaningless as a generic category. We are playing the 2018 Cleveland Browns. No one else.

Backups mostly wouldn’t be backups if they were able to replicate the production of the starters.

An all time record is meaningless. How many of those games came with players and coaches who are still on the rosters? last time we played them was four years ago. Mike smith was our coach. We have at a quick scan a total of nine players in common with that team. assuredly less than that in 2010. Those previous games have no meaning to this coming one. and we aren’t playing “afc teams” we are playing the 2018 Browns.

I'm not addicted to these 'running quarterbacks' like many seems to be. Give me a good pocket passer over _any_run first quarterback.

Gratz - way cool.

So many toys in the toy box ....

Suuden death overtime of any sort whatsoever is dumb. Full stop.

Well, why would a record largely compiled by players who will probably be cut from the team be all that relevant?

Because they were massively sucky replacement quarterbacks trying to play on a team built around a style they couldn't emulate? Backups not being able to win with a team is not in fact an argument for the validity of QB winning percentage as a stat.

As far as Trubisky looking great in a preseason game ... remember Doug Johnson?

Since the title said most/least accurate in the web address ... can anyone say who the list of least accurate was? I have my suspicions.

What sounds like a cult is the circumlocutions you go through to try to pretend that Cam Newton is an accurate thrower.

Well, we ARE talking about PFF here. If you find PFF less than relevant why is that less valid to post than posting it in the first place? Personally, I find PFF's individual player ratings not worth much at all and ill-reflective of reality.